Understanding the Illusion of Control and Anxiety | Calgary Psychology Insights
The Illusion of Control: Why We Feel Safer When We’re Not
Have you ever pressed the elevator button twice even though you knew it wouldn’t make it come faster?
Or re-checked your phone after sending a risky text, as if staring harder could change the reply?
That’s the Illusion of Control — our mind’s quiet superstition that if we just do something, we can make uncertainty less scary.
It’s not madness. It’s survival instinct — and it’s wired into us.
The Science (in Simple Terms)
Psychologist Ellen Langer first studied this in the 1970s. She found that when people felt even a tiny bit of control — like choosing their own lottery ticket instead of being handed one — they valued it more and believed their odds improved.
Same odds. Same randomness.
Different feeling.
Because the human brain doesn’t crave certainty — it craves agency.
We want to feel like we’re steering the ship, even in a storm.
A Story You’ll Recognize
During turbulence on a flight, one passenger grips the armrest, breathes hard, and closes their eyes. Another opens the flight tracker, watches the speed, altitude, and time to destination.
The second person isn’t calmer because they’re safer — they’re calmer because they’ve reclaimed illusionary control.
We do it all the time:
- refreshing emails instead of sitting in uncertainty,
- micromanaging others when we feel powerless,
- overplanning every detail because it feels better than waiting.
It’s our way of saying, “If I can control something, maybe I’ll be okay.”
The Emotional Layer
Control gives the nervous system a sense of safety.
When that control is threatened, our stress response spikes — even if the actual risk hasn’t changed.
So we cling to rituals, overanalyze, or replay “what ifs.”
Ironically, the harder we grip, the less flexible and resilient we become.
It’s like holding sand in your fist — squeeze tighter, lose more.
A Metaphor You’ll Remember
Imagine driving through a rainstorm. You can control the wheel — but not the weather.
Focus too much on the clouds, and you’ll drift.
Grip the steering wheel just enough to stay centered, and trust the road beneath you.
That’s the balance: control what’s yours, surrender what’s not.
How to Hack the Illusion of Control (Without Losing Your Mind)
1️ Separate “Influence” from “Outcome.”
Write down a current stressor.
Underline what’s truly in your influence (your effort, tone, actions).
Cross out what isn’t (others’ reactions, timing, external events).
Direct your energy only toward the underlined parts.
2️ Replace Control With Clarity.
When uncertainty spikes, ask:
“What do I know for sure right now?”
Focusing on facts — not forecasts — grounds your nervous system.
3️ Practice Micro-Surrender.
Each day, release one thing you’ve been forcing: an unanswered text, a delayed plan, a perfectionist standard.
Let it unfold without interference — and notice that nothing collapses.
4️ Create Predictable Anchors.
You can’t control the big stuff, but you can create small pockets of consistency — morning rituals, exercise, journaling.
These tell your brain, “I’m safe enough to let go of the rest.”
5️ Redefine Safety.
Safety doesn’t mean control; it means trust — in yourself, in time, in process.
The less you need to control, the freer you become.
Why This Matters
We think control gives peace, but often it gives pressure.
The moment you realize peace comes from trust, not grip, life gets lighter.
You don’t have to choreograph every outcome to feel safe.
You just have to remember that uncertainty isn’t danger — it’s space.
Space for creativity. For rest. For life to surprise you.
Try This Today
The next time something feels out of your hands, whisper:
“Maybe it doesn’t need my control to work out.”
Breathe. Loosen your grip.
You’ll notice — most things find their way without your micromanagement.
And that’s the real paradox: the less you control, the more in control you actually feel.
Book a clarity session today: Calendly